Honda Odyssey Forum banner
1 - 14 of 14 Posts

maxud

· Registered
Joined
·
2,716 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 · (Edited)
Here is something you don't see much of any more in this forum. A troubleshooting guide for the engine misfire.
I recently got to work on 2007 Honda Odyssey EXL-R, VCM engine.
The owner had been chasing an engine misfire for some time. The story as relayed to me was, spark plugs were changed,
coil swap game was done, valves were adjusted, car continues to misfire, usually cold.
Rule #1, start from scratch, especially since I found a new (aftermarket) coil on cylinder #3 vs #6, it naturally crept in my head that perhaps the
previous techs did not know the order of cylinders.
I have the Helms Service manual, which is excellent and I highly recommend it for anybody doing work on their van.
Observing the van running, the misfire was almost impercetable, definitely not as bad as I expected.
Cylinder #6 is front row right most facing the engine, so its easy to access when engine cover is removed.
I disconnected the coil electrical connector and the misfire beat changed and became worse.
I have a decent code scanner Autel MD802, which was definitely very helpful in this case.

The troubleshooting procedure in Helms says:
1. swap coils - did that, and confirmed misfire stayed with #6.
2. swap plugs - did that, plugs were nice and clean, definitely newish, definitely oem, definitely good gap, again confirmed misfire stayed with #6.

Then I decided to stray off the beaten path and did compression test and leakdown test on cylinder #6. Both showed that there were no issues with the cylinder.

3. swap fuel injectors - now this is a new one on me, to swap injectors, you need to disassemble the intake plenum. Its not a huge job, but still takes time
to take things off, and then reassemble. I did not bother with new gaskets, and was able to confirm that throttle body, upper intake and lower intake gaskets were ok.
I also did not want to just install the new injector because plenty of part swapping was already done to no good effect.

Basic steps on removing plenum are:
Take the battery out, take out air box, remove air intake rubber boot, disconnect throttle body and slide it off the plenum, do not remove from the car, there are some hoses
under it that can stay put. Remove upper intake cover, bunch of small bolts around perimeter and two nuts. Disconnect couple of hoses and electrical connectors from the plenum.
Unbolt a bunch of bolts that were exposed by removing upper cover and two nuts. The plenum should slide up vertically on two rods.
This exposes the split intake manifolds and both fuel rails. Each fuel rail is fastened by two bolts and the fuel hose connector is a simple pinch and release type, no special tool
required. I wrapped it in a clean rug, in case the fuel decided to spray all over. (prior to the job, I pulled fuel pump fuse and cranked the car for a bit to relive fuel pressure, you can do either
fuse or relay). Each fuel injector is held in by a metal clip, that simply pulls out. Each injector has two o-rings, one that sits in the rail and one that goes into intake manifold.

So after getting the fuel rail out, I inspected the injectors. Nothing was obviously wrong with them, so I proceeded to swap #5 and #6.
I put the car together. Then started the car with my scanner connected and observing various misfire pids. Right away I saw that the misfire moved to cylinder #5 and #6 was
in clear. This was the positive diagnosis I was looking for. So it was definitely Fuel injector #6 that was causing an issue.

I bought a replacement part at Advance Auto parts and it was Intermotor brand box. Imagine my surprise when out of the box came Honda OEM packaged injector!
I went for aftermarket due to time crunch and not being able to source the part from Honda dealer on short notice. I was doing the work on Thanksgiving.
The new injector comes with brand new o-rings, so in addition that that, I bought a felpro pack of 4 injector rings to replace both sets of o-rings on the other two injectors.
I replaced the fuel injector with a new one and confirmed that misfires went away. Felt really good to chase this one down.

There might be better ways to test the injector without removing it out of the car, may require a scope or higher end Diagnostic tool.
I often read about engine misfires on these Honda Engines, and don't see a lot of resolutions. This should help a few people out.

picture of upper plenum with cover removed


upper plenum removed


fuel rail for cylinders 4, 5 and 6


new parts


injectors, the new one is the one that has white plastic, the bad one was marked with white paint
 
Nice job tracking down the actual problem! In the future you can often discover a bad injector with a stethoscope if you can get it positively placed against the injector body. Compare the clicking pattern and intensity to a couple other injectors at varying rpms.
 
Discussion starter · #3 ·
Nice job tracking down the actual problem! In the future you can often discover a bad injector with a stethoscope if you can get it positively placed against the injector body. Compare the clicking pattern and intensity to a couple other injectors at varying rpms.
thanks for the tip! In the Ody, the injectors are pretty much hidden by the plenum and access is very restricted, but I can see it working on a different engine!
 
Super post! I've seen the same threads. It's hard to get people to do all the tests to rule out the possibilities. Swap coils, swap plugs, and when that doesn't help they give up when you say to check compression. Diving in to swap injectors is a little time consuming but it paid off here. Nice work.

Yeah, the injectors are buried on the J35. I've seen injector balance tests done and I think the DS708 has some features for that on the Gen 3 Ody but I've not used them yet. I'd need a fuel pressure gauge to go along with it, though, I think.

What's your theory on what went wrong with it? Just dirty and not injecting enough fuel or is there something electrically wrong with the injector? It sounds like it was partially working. The only other tests that you could do would be to check the resistance of the injector or do current ramps on them but current ramps would require a scope, as you mentioned. Were the fuel trims indicating anything out of the norm on this one?

So, in the box was that Honda bag with a new OEM injector in it? Is that the norm for that brand or did someone mistakenly return an unopened Honda injector in an Intermotor box?
 
Discussion starter · #5 ·
John,
I can list all the things that could we wrong with injector, but no idea what is really going on with it. Yeah, it was definitely partially working.
My understanding is that it has to be electro-mechnical in nature. It has 6 tiniest holes, which spray the fuel, so it definitely could have plugged up.
Could be the opposite and it was leaking gas internally, delivering too much fuel. Could be the circuitry. To get the definite diagnosis, one would
need to learn how the computer detects misfire, ie. lack of explosion or premature/late explosion. I am sure knock sensor is involved somehow.
I am sure there are injector testers as well, but at the end of the day, its only $40-$60 part, replace it and move on.

I did not look at the fuel trims, as I kept the run time to the minimum to keep the engine as cold as possible, in order to hopefully replicate the issue.
Every new repair I do, I learn something new. For this one I mostly followed with Diagnostic tree from Service manual.

Yep, in the Intermotor box there was brand new sealed bag of Honda part, I have it in one of the pictures.
I don't think its a norm for the brand nor that someone returned the Honda injector
in the box. I think it essentially comes down to parts availability. First, we know that Honda does not produce most of the parts that go into the Honda vehicle.
There are very few part manufacturers, and then there are Brands like "Intermotor", "Duralast", or "Craftsman", which basically outsource their products
to manufacturers. At the end of the day its a part lottery. If the brand outsourced to more than one manufacturer, you can get two differently made parts in the
similar box. I have seen it with my own eyes recently when I bought a reman Alternator for 2011 Pilot and ended up getting two Advance auto house brands.
One was reman in China, one in Mexico. Bearings is another example, where you can get Timken bearing box, but who knows whats inside anymore.
Long story short, if someone needs a new injector, check Advance auto and possibly get brand new honda injector for half the price.

Max
 
John,
I can list all the things that could we wrong with injector, but no idea what is really going on with it...
I was just wondering if there was anything you could see visually or if you checked it with a meter. You're right, though, it could even be that it's not closing completely. Fuel trims before and after might have given a hint on that. Regardless of what happened to it I really appreciate the post.
 
Hi all,
First time posting on the site. I don't have a lot of experience with engines, so trying to learn as I go.
I have a 2010 Odyssey EXL. I have had some interittment problems with the check engine light and some misfires. It often cleared up before I got to my local mechanic. He indicated he had seen this before and mentioned they tend to use oil, so I should keep oil levels up and I should be fine. This seemed to be working, but last week it started misfiring again and losing power. I had it towed to the local dealer. Their diagnosis was bad spark plugs and it needed the cylinders adjusted ~$1000. I got a call later when the work was completed, but it didn't resolve the misfire which was on cylinder 6. The next day they did a compression test on cylinder 6 and it apparently failed, they also found oil on the spark plug(s). Now they believe I have a burnt valve that needs replaced which is roughly $3000. Researching on this site and the internet I found the class action law suit involving cylinders 1-3. Not knowing a lot about engines, I see potential for some correlation here, but the dealer assures me this isn't possible. I asked for some help with the repairs given the history with misfires, but the dealer refused. I am awaiting a case with Honda North America now, but the rep who took my complaint didn't think it would go anywhere. My local mechanic has another client who just had a similar issue with cylinder 3 & 6 (trying to verify cylinders involved with that customer yet) and NA Honda covered 90% of the bill. Same dealer, same service advisor, but they denied knowing anything about this. My vehicle has 200,000 miles on it and otherwise is in good condition and we were hoping to get another 50,000 out of it.
Does anyone have thoughts if my #6 issue could be related to known problems on #1-3? Anything else I should ask the dealer or push back with? Will it be a money pit if I invest in the repair, or do these have good outcomes once fixed? Anything you can share would be beneficial. Sorry, I don't have the codes that were found, but could try to get them. I don't have much faith in my service advisor. I appreciate the knowledge of all on this site! This is my 5th Honda, so I have been loyal, but this is making me reconsider.

I also have a 2010 Accord with a similar issue. I am concerned I will repeat this scenario on that vehicle. The dealer looked up the history and said something had already been done on the Accord to avoid this. Do I need to sell this before my daughters are stranded on the roadside with it?

Thanks all!
 
It is very likely your issue was caused by VCM. It might have been avoided if VCM was disabled (muzzled) long ago. You may still want to install a VCM muzzler device.
 
Discussion starter · #12 ·
It is very likely your issue was caused by VCM. It might have been avoided if VCM was disabled (muzzled) long ago. You may still want to install a VCM muzzler device.
Cylinder 6 has absolutely nothing to do with VCM. No compression is likely burned up valve, which do happen on Hondas/Acuras.
Thats why valve adjustments need to be performed.
 
Cylinder 6 has absolutely nothing to do with VCM. No compression is likely burned up valve, which do happen on Hondas/Acuras.
Thats why valve adjustments need to be performed.
Assuming of course that it is actually cylinder 6 and not another cylinder that OP thinks is cylinder 6.
 
Discussion starter · #14 ·
1 - 14 of 14 Posts