Honda Odyssey Forum banner
1 - 8 of 8 Posts

DougDeVore1

· Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
Hey all-

I just wanted to say thanks to everyone for the support over the years. I've lurked for years and only posted a hand full of times when I was desperate.

I really applicate the guys that posted the DIY brakes, tranny flush, and a few other things. Having owned two odyssey's and putting almost a 400k on them, it feels weird not having a honda in the family now.

My 2006 EXL\RES was fantastic! I only got grumpy about the AC problems, but 260k on the clock and still going strong when traded its hard to say a bad word about it.

The 2012 EXL\RES was a different sad story and what really caused me to switch. I had to get rid of her with only 140k on the clock. The entire time I owned that van I fought a wobble in the steering causing me and the service writers to get to know each other on a first name basis. I put more tires on that van getting it to 140k than I did with my old van to 250K! They replaced half-shafts, countless alignments, rotors to no avail (my cost!). At about 70K I had to replace the plugs because it developed a miss on a couple cylinders. Then at 122k when I was having the struts replaced ($1000!) I mentioned it having a miss again. Since there was a service bulletin about this problem, he was able to get honda to cover what turned out to be major engine work (cylinder 4 and 3 piston ring gaps where aligned). Finally at 140k it developed a knock in the lower crankcase where all the major work was previously done, but only had a 12k warranty. I really wanted to keep this van (just put Michelin defenders on it!), but was advised to trade sooner than later. Maybe it was a fluke, but lack of maintenance was not an issue (amsoil).

Who knows, maybe the toyota will be a "fluke" too? :) I did just learn they don't have timing belts, but chains. Kind of looking forward to not messing with that.

Thanks again guys!
 
(cylinder 4 and 3 piston ring gaps where aligned)
Sounds like another case of damage caused by VCM. VCM has really tarnished what used to be a bulletproof engine. (Luckily we have the VCMuzzler.)

The Sienna is a very reliable vehicle, even beyond the timing chain vs. timing belt.

Best wishes with the new ride.

Dave
 
I have owned an '05, '06 and a '13 Odyssey. I then purchased a 2017 Sienna when my sister got a great deal on hers. Drove the Sienna for 6 month/10000 miles...sold it a couple of weeks ago and picked up a low mile 2015 Odyssey. So happy to be back in an Odyssey. The Sienna was way to cushy for me and the new 8-speed transmission was constantly hunting for gears. Don't get me wrong, the Sienna is a great van, just not for me.
 
Yup. I had a Siennaand loved it, but I went for a 2014 Ody, because the console is removable (Imake furniture as a hobby and need to haul long boards). I knew about the transmission and VCM issues,but took a chance. Bad move. Why would anyone ever spend money on a carthat they know has mechanical problems? Even with the muzzeler and the transmission flush the van is no where assmooth or reliable as the Sienna. I washoping for a 2018 Sienna hybrid , but they newer introduced one –so I waitanother year to get away from Honda. Most of the other differences between thetwo vehicles are really minor and people just get used to them. For example: when the Ody seats are foldeddown you don’t have a flat cargo area, but a nice teeter totter.
 
Plenty of stories of either brand failing. As I see it stick to what you like and are familiar with. I have had good luck with Honda so I will likely stay with it in the future. Good luck with the Sienna but just remember that every brand has their horror stories. My 2011 Touring is over 165K miles now and still running like new. I hope to keep it that way for another 135K miles before I'm willing to part ways!
 
keep an eye on front struts, I have a customer with Sienna that keeps blowing them. He is on a 3rd set now and they are leaking again ~60k miles.
Another thing on the Sienna is timing chain cover is leaking oil. I see this on many Toyota engines.
 
1 - 8 of 8 Posts