I only use Econ mode on the highway. It's practically unusable (not technically, just a personal feeling) in the city as the power is not there to do any proper acceleration. On the highway however, once you're at speed and you just need to maintain or slightly move up a bit at times, you don't notice the difference. But accelerating from a full stop with Econ mode is just really not enjoyable. I recently used Econ mode almost entirely for a roadtrip and did roughly the fuel economy that Honda advertises for highway mileage. I'm not sure if their figures assume Econ mode overall though.
So I don't think it's correct that Econ mode doesn't work on the highway, in fact the bottom part of that article tyman was sourcing (here:
https://www.kirklandhonda.com/what-is-honda-econ-button/) says the below:
When Should I Not Use Honda’s Econ Button?
- On very hot days.
- When merging on and off the highway
- Overtaking other vehicles on the road.
- Towing large amounts.
- On dangerous roads steep hills.
You shouldn’t use Honda’s Econ button if you’re merging onto a highway, since you’ll need to accelerate quite rapidly. If you’re driving down precarious roads, you should also keep your Honda’s Econ button disengaged, since both throttle response and transmission change with the Econ button on.
When to Use Honda Econ Button
- Cruising at a steady pace on the highway
- Normal city driving conditions
- Areas where the terrain remains relatively flat
- You aren’t towing anything
- On days that aren’t unbearably hot and you won’t need to use max A/C for long
Hope that helps.