[New Dad New Van]

That would be a possibility, especially if your spare key works better.

Also, the 1999 model year had an ignition switch recall and the symptoms are similar to what you are describing with your primary key.

 

[OdyinNH]

If you mean you cannot turn the key without jiggling then get some new keys cut. Many places now make these keys but I think there's a process for the van to learn the new security side of the key.

 

[yeoldeoddy]

Not sure if the 99 has a different key, but the 2000 has a security chip inside that is read by some electronic device near the iginition switch. I couldn't find anyone that could duplicate it except the dealer. It wasn't super expensive (like the new key/remote security keys) I think it was around $20.

 

[Xrrman]

Here's an update on my key problem. I went to the local Honda dealer with my spare key and ran through the problem with a manager in the parts dept. The first thing he said was I probably needed an ignition switch (to the tune of $350).

I suggested that since the spare key was working fine, why don't we try cutting another one and trying that first? Anyway, he got called out of the room on another matter and another fellow behind the counter said he'd cut a new key for $30 and that would probably do the trick. Sure enough, five days later and after numerous starts the new key hasn't missed once.

No wonder the service center can afford La-Z-Boys and flat screens all over the waiting area......

 

[OdyinNH]

That's why I dislike dealerships. How about try the cheap fix first and go from there. BTW, if it turns with one key and not the others then it would not be the switch which is electrical. It could be the tumbler section though. The actual switch is on the opposite side of the stearing column and is turned by a small piece of metal (or maybe it's plastic, I forget).