what is the mechanism called that is used to keep the driver/passenger open, middle of the door? Mine keeps wanting to close on me before I get in.

1947 Views 42 Replies 10 Participants Last post by dvpatel, 3 mo ago

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · 3 mo ago

I wanted to search it but all i get is threads on locked doors, door latches, everything BUT what I need.

2001 Odyssey.

i've included a pic. Thanks for any help naming this part. This one is shot.

Door Wood Fixture Auto part Metal

See less See more

Status: Not open for further replies.

21 - 40 of 43 Posts

Juggawut

· #21 · 3 mo ago

@WiiMaster are you saying that your factory stock door checks are still operating normally?

I call both my front doors "shin busters" and have to warn EVERYONE that gets in that they're about to be assaulted by their door.

I have also read that they fail again not that long after replacement, even if you buy the Honda OE parts, which is why I never replaced them. Can anyone confirm?

I mean it's cool having self-closing front doors, as I have grown accustomed to getting out and just walking away from the van without closing my driver door, as I know it will close by itself behind me, and it always does.

Dorman parts are more of "in a pinch" replacements, but I would definitely not trust anything with the Dorman name on it that had moving (mechanical) components.

Reactions: 1

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #22 · 3 mo ago

It was only $15 for the part. Why would I pay the OEM markup for a Honda part on a 22 year old minivan.
If it wears out on 3 days, I've only lost $15 and my time.
Are your shins worth $15? To me, some people like to complain rather than fix the problem. It's easier.

Reactions: 1

Buffalo4

· #23 · 3 mo ago

azmusclecar said:
It was only $15 for the part. Why would I pay the OEM markup for a Honda part on a 22 year old minivan.
If it wears out on 3 days, I've only lost $15 and my time.
Are your shins worth $15? To me, some people like to complain rather than fix the problem. It's easier.

Keep us informed. If they work out, I will probably buy some.
Thanks,
Buffalo4

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #24 · 3 mo ago

Buffalo4 said:
Keep us informed. If they work out, I will probably buy some.
Thanks,
Buffalo4

Will do. I hope I won't need to post a pic of bloody shins and an amputated foot as some have suggested
they'd rather have than fixing the issue.

Juggawut

· #25 · 3 mo ago

azmusclecar said:
It was only $15 for the part. Why would I pay the OEM markup for a Honda part on a 22 year old minivan.
If it wears out on 3 days, I've only lost $15 and my time.
Are your shins worth $15? To me, some people like to complain rather than fix the problem. It's easier.

I wouldn't waste the time, let alone $15 for a part from a brand widely regarded as having a high failure rate. You may enjoy "taking the lord's name in vain" and needing to stop for lunch to clear your head and introducing a whole slew of new problems in the process. It sounds like this was quite a trial for you.

"Buy once cry once." That's all I'm saying. Fix it right the first time.

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #26 · 3 mo ago

No it was an education for me at the cost of $15. I was just being honest, as in it was a challenge for me. I'm 71 and due to some physical disabliites, it wasn't easy. I believe you've made your case for why you wouldn't do it and won't do it.

I posted what I found, thought and did. You are free to criticise this thread or anyother thread you wish to.

If nothing else, now when I go to replace the inop passenger door power lock solenoid, the door panel removal will be easier knowing what I know. So to me, it was a worthwhile challenge or adventure with sure some bumps along the way.

Reactions: 2

kernel

· #27 · 3 mo ago

Kudos to you! Many hold a degree from the 'school of hard knocks' in higher regard than those with 'book smarts'!

And pulling those door cards should go easier the next time. Just remember to pull those hidden screws out before pulling off the panel. Working from the bottom is best. And don't forget to redo those wire connectors and clips that had to be undone! And I agree, those $15 door checkers might even work better than OEM!

Reactions: 1

Juggawut

· #28 · 3 mo ago

azmusclecar said:
No it was an education for me at the cost of $15. I was just being honest, as in it was a challenge for me. I'm 71 and due to some physical disabliites, it wasn't easy. I believe you've made your case for why you wouldn't do it and won't do it.

I posted what I found, thought and did. You are free to criticise this thread or anyother thread you wish to.

If nothing else, now when I go to replace the inop passenger door power lock solenoid, the door panel removal will be easier knowing what I know. So to me, it was a worthwhile challenge or adventure with sure some bumps along the way.

Most of us gain wisdom with age, and have a firm understanding of how valuable our time is.

If you want to assume that I wouldn't fix it, be my guest. You know what happens when you assume.

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #29 · 3 mo ago

You never know until you try. I mean I could have always taken it to my Honda Dealership and had them do it and install ther overpriced part and be satisfied with handing them a check and what did I learn from that?? If you think education is expensive, you should see what ignorance costs you. My passenger door panel awaits me. Have a great day. 👍

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #30 · 3 mo ago

Juggawut said:
Most of us gain wisdom with age, and have a firm understanding of how valuable our time is.

If you want to assume that I wouldn't fix it, be my guest. You know what happens when you assume.

Don't you have other threads needing your attention.......you've made your point........move on. Please. And please post YOUR thread if and when you fix yours so we can all read it.
I look forward to it.....as I'm sure others do as well.

Juggawut

· #31 · 3 mo ago

azmusclecar said:
Don't you have other threads needing your attention.......you've made your point........move on. Please. And please post YOUR thread if and when you fix yours so we can all read it.
I look forward to it.....as I'm sure others do as well.

I don't think I'd need to make a thread for it, there may already be some. And you'd give me a big head if you said anyone looked forward to my posts.

If it has to be said, I don't plan to replace them until I replace the speakers in the doors, which is a back burner project for me. There is no immediate need to replace either component.

I learned to wrench the way you did doing this job. Trial and error, divide and conquer, and fix it right the first time, which also means using quality parts.

You plead the case of this being a pretty rough job, and my only opinion on your experience is that you've used a brand of parts that is known for its failure rates and that I would have researched which part to buy before pulling the trigger.

I applaud your effort in getting this job one, I know how intense delving inside a door can be if you've never done it before.

See less See more

WiiMaster

· #32 · 3 mo ago

Juggawut said:
@WiiMaster are you saying that your factory stock door checks are still operating normally?

Correct. I even went out to it this morning to grab a mileage photo. Works great at each detent.

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #33 · 3 mo ago

Juggawut said:
I don't think I'd need to make a thread for it, there may already be some. And you'd give me a big head if you said anyone looked forward to my posts.

If it has to be said, I don't plan to replace them until I replace the speakers in the doors, which is a back burner project for me. There is no immediate need to replace either component.

I learned to wrench the way you did doing this job. Trial and error, divide and conquer, and fix it right the first time, which also means using quality parts.

You plead the case of this being a pretty rough job, and my only opinion on your experience is that you've used a brand of parts that is known for its failure rates and that I would have researched which part to buy before pulling the trigger.

I applaud your effort in getting this job one, I know how intense delving inside a door can be if you've never done it before.

Funny how few posts I have, and you have 1200 posts........wow. I see you hide your profile. I wonder how many threads you start. Or do you just go around and comment on everyone elses? Odd how you can amass 1200 posts in as little two years and four months. You must spend a lot of time on here sharing your wisdom, skills and abilities.

I guess you really do make this forum a better place. Gee how I wish I would have found your thread on replacing the door checker first. It may have saved me a lot of work and $15 since I'm mechanically challenged. Please, start threads so I can come see and read the expertise of someone with all the answers. It will save a lot of members a lot of time.
And your post count will grow and grow and grow.........heck I'lll even subscribe to your threads.

See less See more

Juggawut

· #34 · 3 mo ago

Eh, can't help every salty curmudgeon.

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #35 · 3 mo ago

Oh come come now, you are too modest.......surely.........you are the benchmark by which we must measure all others.
Are you trolling me to build up your post count, or mine?

Juggawut

· #36 · 3 mo ago

azmusclecar said:
Oh come come now, you are too modest.......surely.........you are the benchmark by which we must measure all others.
Are you trolling me to build up your post count, or mine?

You've been trolling me since I first commented. One immature snarky comment after another. It's like arguing with a child about which is the best Pokémon. Sorry for hurting your feelings so profoundly. Not everyone is here to pat you on the back and tell you what a great job you did so you don't feel bad.

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #37 · 3 mo ago

Juggawut said:
You've been trolling me since I first commented. One immature snarky comment after another. It's like arguing with a child about which is the best Pokémon. Sorry for hurting your feelings so profoundly. Not everyone is here to pat you on the back and tell you what a great job you did so you don't feel bad.

I think we should let the members decide who started trolling........I'm just a newbee with very few posts. My history doesn't show trolling. While you were replying, I was out honing my mechanical skills so someday I can be a legend in my mind like some folks on here, who know it all.
I've been on plenty of forums in my life, and there's always someone like..............well..........we needn't name names.
You don't like snarky but you can dish it out. Hurts when you meet your match and you're called out.
I 'll keep posting my threads and you come back and post your .............whatever. It makes you feel better rather than posting anything positive, I believe you are the curmudgeon. And that is a pretty big word.............for the rest of us.
Thanks for sharing it. I'll be sure to use it. Oh wait I just did. OH LOOK ANOTHER POST FOR ME!!!!

See less See more

azmusclecar

Discussion Starter · #38 · 3 mo ago

Oh and finally, I don't need post counts like some folks to make me feel like I'm important. I'm okay with who I am.
I've enjoyed your posts contrary to what you may think. You have been a great source of entertainment for me and maybe some others. Thanks for playing along...what do we have for parting gifts Johnny????.

I've asked the moderator to lock this thread since it's not producing any results positive to the thread. You're welcome.

2011.2017.odyssey

· #39 · 3 mo ago

well that escalated quickly...

Here I am missing all the fun... AGAIN.

Reactions: 1

dvpatel

· #40 · 3 mo ago

2011.2017.odyssey said:
well that escalated quickly...

Here I am missing all the fun... AGAIN.

Me too. Was stuck on the tarmac for 3 hours due to a ground stop. Now I gotta slice and dice this mess. I’ll have to do this next week when I’m back home. 😂

Reactions: 1

21 - 40 of 43 Posts

Status: Not open for further replies.