It depends on the winter conditions you drive in. If it's occasional snow and mostly dry or wet pavement, something like the Nokian WRG2 will do great. For deeper snow and ice, I'm partial to the Nokian RSI (which way outperformed the X-Ice in my experience). On our Odyssey right now we've got the Toyo Observe snow tires with bits of walnut shell in the tread. Eastern MA winters are some deep snow and lots of slush and icy muck and the Toyos do really well.